Options Collar Explained: The Strategy Mark Cuban Used to Protect His Wealth
Meta Description: Uncover the options collar spread strategy, a favorite of Mark Cuban. Learn how it works, its uses, benefits, risks, and how to optimize it for your portfolio.
Mark Cuban and the Options Collar: A Winning Strategy
Mark Cuban, billionaire entrepreneur and savvy investor, has a well-documented history of using options strategies to protect and profit from his investments. One of his most famous moves involved the options collar, a strategy that played a role in his success story.
Before we dive into the mechanics of the options collar spread, let's understand why Cuban might have turned to this particular approach. Cuban made his early fortune with the sale of his company, [invalid URL removed], to Yahoo! in 1999. A significant portion of his wealth was tied up in Yahoo! stock. While optimistic about Yahoo's prospects, he likely wanted a way to protect those holdings from a potential market downturn. This is where the options collar came into play.
What is an Options Collar?
In its most basic form, an options collar spread involves three core components:
Long Stock: You already own shares of the underlying stock.
Long Put: You purchase a put option with an out-of-the-money (OTM) strike price. This gives you the right to sell your shares at that strike price, offering downside protection in case the stock price falls.
Short Call: You sell a call option with an out-of-the-money (OTM) strike price. This brings in premium income but caps your profit potential if the stock price rises sharply.
The main purpose of an options collar spread is to hedge a long stock position. It provides a level of downside protection while somewhat limiting potential upside gains in exchange for collecting premium on the short call.
How Did the Options Collar Help Mark Cuban?
Let's assume Cuban owned a substantial amount of Yahoo! stock after the [invalid URL removed] acquisition. By implementing an options collar, he essentially established a protective floor for his holdings while also retaining some potential for growth. If Yahoo! shares experienced a significant downturn, Cuban's put options would gain value, offsetting some of the losses on his stock position.
Conversely, if Yahoo! performed moderately well, the losses on the short call would be outweighed by gains in the stock itself. Only if Yahoo's stock price skyrocketed would the sold call options severely limit Cuban's potential profit.
The options collar likely provided Cuban with the balance he needed – protection for his substantial wealth tied to Yahoo! stock, while still allowing for some potential upside if the company continued to grow.
Mechanics of the Options Collar Spread
Now, let's break down how to actually execute an options collar spread step-by-step:
1. Start with a Long Stock Position: The collar is designed to hedge an existing long position in a stock. So, you'll need to already own shares.
2. Buy a Long Put Option: Choose a put option with an out-of-the-money (OTM) strike price below the current stock price. The expiration date should align with your desired holding period for the stock. Remember, the put option provides your downside protection.
3. Sell a Short Call Option: Select a call option with an out-of-the-money (OTM) strike price above the current stock price. Ideally, the expiration date should match that of your put option. The short call caps your upside but also brings in premium income to offset the cost of the put option.
Example Scenario:
Let's say you own 100 shares of XYZ stock currently trading at $100 per share.
You purchase one put option contract with a strike price of $95 and an expiration date three months out. This gives you the right to sell 100 shares of XYZ at $95, even if the market price drops well below that.
You simultaneously sell one call option contract with a strike price of $105 and the same expiration date. This obligates you to sell 100 shares of XYZ at $105 if the buyer exercises the option.
Benefits of Using an Options Collar
Downside Protection: The primary benefit of the options collar is the insurance it provides against sharp declines in your underlying stock position. The long put option sets a floor, limiting potential losses.
Cost Reduction: Selling the call option helps cover the cost of purchasing the put. In ideal scenarios, you may even achieve a "zero-cost collar" where the premium income completely offsets the put option expense.
Potential for Upside: While the short call option does limit your ultimate upside potential, you still can benefit from stock price increases until the strike price of your short call is reached.
Risks to Consider with an Options Collar
Capped Upside: If the stock you hold surges significantly in price, your short-call option can limit your maximum profit potential. The buyer of the call you sold has the right to buy your shares at the strike price, even if the market price is much higher.
Premiums: You'll need to pay the premium upfront to buy the put option. Be sure to factor this expense into your calculations.
Early Assignment Risk: There's always a chance that the short-call option you've sold could be exercised prior to expiration, especially if the stock experiences a sharp price increase. This would force you to sell your shares at the strike price.
Is the Options Collar Spread Right for You?
The options collar spread isn't a one-size-fits-all strategy. It best suits certain scenarios and investor profiles. Here's how to determine if it makes sense for you:
Scenarios Where an Options Collar Might Be a Good Fit:
Moderate Bullishness with Risk Aversion: You are generally optimistic about a particular stock you own, but you're concerned about a potential market correction or unexpected negative news impacting that company.
Pre-Earnings Protection: You want to hedge your holdings ahead of a major company announcement like an earnings report, where volatility is expected.
Desire for Income Generation: You're willing to give up some upside potential in exchange for generating premium income from the short-call option.
When an Options Collar Might NOT Be the Right Choice:
Extremely Bullish View: If you're incredibly bullish on a stock and expect explosive price growth, an options collar would severely limit your potential gains.
Seeking Maximum Downside Protection: If your primary worry is a catastrophic drop in the stock price, buying put options outright might provide more robust protection (though at a higher cost).
Risk-Tolerant Investor: If you have a high risk appetite and are comfortable with potential volatility, the options collar might offer more protection than you need.
Variations on the Options Collar
The traditional options collar spread can be modified to fine-tune your risk/reward profile:
Adjusting Strike Prices: A wider collar, with strike prices further out-of-the-money, provides greater downside protection but also limits your profit potential more significantly. A tighter collar has closer strike prices, giving you higher upside potential but less protection.
Altering Expiration Dates: You can use different expiration dates for the call and put options, creating more tailored strategies based on your time horizon for holding the underlying stock.
Tips for Implementing an Options Collar
Choosing Strike Prices: Selecting the right strike prices is crucial for the success of your collar. You want a put option offering meaningful downside protection and a call option that isn't too likely to be exercised unless you're comfortable selling your shares at that price. Typically Selling a call near 1 standard deviation to the upside and buying a put at 1 standard deviation to the downside yields a positive THETA position and hedges well for a large move.
This is not financial advice and all examples are hypothetical
Timing: Consider market conditions and events that could increase volatility when deciding to enter or exit an options collar.
Tools and Resources: Options collar calculators can help you visualize the potential payoffs and break-even points of different collar structures.
Conclusion
The options collar spread provides a measured way to protect your stock holdings while giving up some upside potential. The strategy resonated with Mark Cuban's investment philosophy in building his substantial wealth. By understanding the mechanics, benefits, risks, and variations, you can determine if the options collar spread aligns with your own investment goals and risk tolerance.
Options are a great way to diversify and augment your investments. If you would like to learn more about options and how we trade SPX Options join our Options Behind the Scenes for free.
